How to Choose Baby Formula: Types, Signs It Suits Your Baby, Switching and Safe Preparation

Start with a standard infant formula and judge it by your baby’s stools, spit-up, skin and weight gain, not brand or price. Allergy formulas need a doctor. How to switch and prepare formula safely with 70°C water.

How to Choose Baby Formula: Types, Signs It Suits Your Baby, Switching and Safe Preparation

The most reliable way to choose baby formula is to start with a standard infant formula suited to your baby’s age, then judge whether it suits your baby by their stools, spit-up, skin and weight gain rather than by brand or price. Infant formula sold in shops has to meet legal nutrient standards — in the US, for example, the FDA requires every infant formula to contain 30 nutrients a growing baby needs — so the basic nutrition is covered whichever one you pick.

Formulas for suspected allergy and specialized medical formulas are for use after talking to your pediatrician, not something to choose on your own. And whatever you choose, the rules for making it up are the same: use water at 70°C (158°F) or above, make one feed at a time, and throw away any formula not drunk within 2 hours.

Standing in front of a shelf full of formula tins, it’s easy to feel lost. This guide walks through the types of formula, how to think about brand and price, how to tell whether a formula suits your baby, how to switch, and how to prepare it safely, based on guidance from the WHO, the NHS and the American Academy of Pediatrics.

What all standard infant formulas have in common

A baby held in an adult’s arms, holding a bottle with both hands and drinking formula

Standard infant formula — usually based on cow’s milk — is made to replace breast milk when breastfeeding isn’t possible, and it comes as powder you mix with water or as ready-to-feed liquid. Because it’s made to set nutrient rules covering energy, protein, fat, vitamins and minerals such as iron and calcium, brands don’t differ in whether they meet those basics.

What differs between brands is what they choose to emphasize on top of those rules: particular added ingredients, the source of the milk, the form it comes in and the price. That’s why the more useful question is not “which formula is best?” but “which formula does my baby do well on?”

The main types of formula and when each is used

It helps to sort formula into three groups: standard infant formula, formula for cow’s milk allergy, and specialized medical formula. Most babies start on standard infant formula.

Type

What it is

When it’s used

Standard infant formula

The basic formula, made to legal nutrient standards; powder or ready-to-feed liquid

Healthy babies who are formula-fed or combination-fed

Formula for cow’s milk allergy

Milk proteins fully broken down (extensively hydrolyzed), or made from amino acids

When a doctor has diagnosed cow’s milk protein allergy and recommends it

Specialized medical formula

Composition adjusted for a specific condition

Premature babies, inherited metabolic conditions and other needs managed by a doctor

Follow-on and toddler formula

Products marketed for older babies and toddlers

Not a required step; see below

1. Standard infant formula: where to start

Most healthy babies grow well on standard infant formula, whether it’s their only milk or used alongside breastfeeding. Products do vary in how they build their protein and fat and in extras such as added prebiotics, so babies can feed or poo a little differently on different brands even though all meet the same rules. That’s why watching your baby after you choose matters.

2. Powder, ready-to-feed and pre-measured formats

The same standard formula can come in different forms. Ready-to-feed liquid formula needs no mixing, which makes it handy for outings, night feeds and emergencies. It tends to cost more, and once opened it needs to be used quickly. Don’t add water to it; follow the instructions on the pack, and throw away whatever your baby leaves. Storage rules and shelf life vary by product, so check the label if you keep some in reserve.

Pre-measured sticks or tablets of powder save you measuring each feed. Many families use a mix of tins and ready-to-feed depending on the situation.

3. Formula for cow’s milk allergy: used after a diagnosis

Extensively hydrolyzed formulas, where the milk proteins are fully broken down, and amino-acid formulas are used when a doctor has diagnosed cow’s milk protein allergy. In the UK they’re prescribed by a GP. They aren’t better than standard formula for every baby, and they cost more.

The one that often causes confusion is partially hydrolyzed or “comfort” formula. The NHS notes that partly hydrolyzed formula is not suitable for babies with cow’s milk allergy. So rather than picking a tin because the label sounds gentle on tummies, talk to your pediatrician first if eczema, blood in the stool or other symptoms are worrying you.

4. Specialized medical formula: used on a doctor’s advice

Some formulas are made for babies born early or with inherited metabolic conditions. These aren’t everyday shelf choices; they’re used under the direction and supervision of your baby’s doctor.

5. Do you need to move on to follow-on or toddler formula?

It’s easy to assume you should switch to follow-on formula once solids start, but it isn’t a required step. The NHS says research shows switching to follow-on formula at 6 months has no benefits for your baby, and that unless a health professional suggests otherwise, first infant formula is the only formula your baby needs in the first year. The American Academy of Pediatrics likewise says toddler formulas are not a necessary part of a healthy child’s diet.

If solids aren’t going well, weight gain is slow, or you’re unsure how to move away from formula around the first birthday, bring it up at your baby’s next check-up.

How to think about brand and price

Since infant formulas are made to the same legal standards, look at how your baby does on a formula before you look at the brand name or the price tag. Premium doesn’t automatically mean better nutrition. Prices tend to reflect things like organic or goat’s milk sourcing and how many added ingredients a product highlights.

A few practical tips:

  • Compare the cost per 100 mL (or per ounce) of made-up formula, not the price per tin. Work out how much prepared milk a tin makes and the real difference becomes clear

  • Don’t start with the biggest tin. Try a small size or sticks for a few days and see how your baby feeds and what their stools look like before committing

  • Consider staying with the formula used in hospital for a while after you go home, so one less thing changes during an already big adjustment

  • Read the label: the age range, preparation instructions, ingredients and allergen information, and storage directions

How to tell whether a formula suits your baby

Whether a formula suits your baby shows up in how your baby is after feeds more than on the ingredients list. When you start or change a formula, keep a slightly closer eye on the following for a few days.

What to watch

Signs it’s probably suiting them

Signs to look into

Feeding

Usually finishes their normal amount

Refuses or takes clearly less than usual

Tummy and spit-up

Settled after feeds

Forceful vomiting that keeps happening

Stools

Color and frequency don’t change much

Ongoing diarrhea or constipation, or blood in the stool

Skin

No redness, eczema or hives

Eczema or hives after feeds

Weight

Following their growth curve at check-ups

Gaining clearly more slowly

Right after a change, stool color or frequency may shift a little. For how to tell an adjustment from a sign worth acting on, see signs your baby’s formula might not be the right fit and what to check before switching.

How to switch formula

When you switch, change only one thing at a time and watch the signs in the table above for a few days. If you change the formula, the teat and the feeding routine all at once, it’s hard to tell what caused any problem.

If you’d like to switch gradually, the simplest way is to increase the number of feeds each day that use the new formula. The key point: make up every bottle with just one formula, exactly as its own label says. Scoop sizes and mixing ratios differ between products, so putting two powders in one bottle, or estimating amounts, can make the feed too strong or too weak. Formula made stronger or weaker than directed can make babies unwell — over-diluted formula can upset the balance of salts and minerals in a baby’s body.

There’s no official rule for how many days a switch should take; go at your baby’s pace. If you’re switching for a medical reason such as a suspected allergy, follow your doctor’s instructions.

Safe preparation: 70°C water and the 2-hour rule

However you choose, the basics of making formula are the same. Powdered formula isn’t sterile, and bacteria can also get in after the tin is opened. That’s why the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) guidelines recommend making up powdered formula with water at no less than 70°C (158°F), which kills bacteria such as Cronobacter (formerly Enterobacter sakazakii) that can make young babies seriously ill.

At home, the steps are:

  • Clean the surface where you’ll make the feed and wash your hands with soap

  • Boil fresh drinking water and pour the correct amount, still at 70°C or above, into a clean, sterilized bottle. Don’t use water left for more than 30 minutes after boiling

  • Add exactly the amount of powder the label says, using the scoop that comes with that formula. More or less powder than directed could make your baby ill

  • Swirl or shake gently until fully dissolved, taking care not to scald yourself

  • Cool it straight away under cold running water or in a bowl of cold or iced water, keeping the water below the bottle’s cap

  • Drip a little on the inside of your wrist: it should feel warm or cool, not hot

  • Throw away any feed not drunk within 2 hours

A few more points. Never warm formula in a microwave: it heats unevenly and can burn your baby’s mouth. Make one feed at a time, and don’t give leftover or previously made-up formula. Keep an opened tin tightly closed in a cool, dry place and use it within the time stated on the label. Wash bottles and teats after every feed and sterilize them by boiling, steam or a sterilizer.

When to get medical help right away

If after a feed your baby is struggling to breathe or very wheezy, has sudden swelling of the lips, mouth or tongue, turns blue, grey or pale, or is limp, floppy or not responding as usual, this may be a serious allergic reaction. Call emergency services (911 in the US, 999 in the UK) straight away, even if they seem to improve.

See a doctor promptly if your baby:

  • keeps vomiting forcefully after feeds

  • has blood in their stool or ongoing diarrhea

  • gets eczema or hives after drinking formula

  • is feeding clearly less and having fewer wet diapers

  • is gaining weight clearly more slowly

Cow’s milk is one of the most common food allergens, and in babies a reaction can show up as tummy symptoms such as vomiting, diarrhea or blood in the stool. Rather than switching formulas again and again on your own, note when and how much your baby fed and what you noticed, and take that to the doctor; it makes the cause much easier to find.

Keeping notes makes changes easier to see

You often can’t tell whether a formula suits your baby from a single feed; it becomes clear when you look at several days side by side. Short notes on feed times and amounts, stools and any skin changes make before-and-after comparison much easier.

If you log feed times, amounts and how your baby seemed afterward in Babyfolio, you can look back at how feeding amounts and intervals changed around the day you switched formula. It’s also a ready record to show your pediatrician.

Frequently asked questions

Should we keep using the formula the hospital gave us?

You don’t have to, but the first weeks home are a big adjustment, so staying with the same formula for a while means one less change. If you want to switch for cost or availability, do it once your baby is settled, one change at a time.

My baby won’t finish the amount on the tin. Does that mean the formula doesn’t suit them?

The amounts on the tin are averages, and babies vary. Look at the total over the day, your baby’s mood and their weight gain rather than any single feed. For typical amounts by age, see what to check when you’re worried about your newborn’s formula intake, feeding intervals and weight gain. If weight gain is slow, talk to your pediatrician.

Can I make up bottles in advance for night feeds or outings?

It’s best to make one feed at a time. You can keep water hot in a flask or a formula kettle that holds 70°C or above, but don’t make up formula with water that has cooled below 70°C. For outings and night feeds, ready-to-feed liquid formula can help.

The short version

When choosing baby formula, start with a standard infant formula and judge it by how your baby does, not by brand or price. Infant formulas are made to the same legal standards, so ask “does it suit my baby?” rather than “which is best?”

Allergy and specialized medical formulas come after a conversation with your doctor, and follow-on or toddler formula isn’t a required step. Whatever you use, make it with water at 70°C or above, one feed at a time, and throw away anything not drunk within 2 hours. If something keeps worrying you, don’t carry it alone; ask your pediatrician.


Sources

  • World Health Organization and Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations — “Safe preparation, storage and handling of powdered infant formula: guidelines” (2007) who.int

  • NHS — “Making up baby formula” nhs.uk

  • NHS — “Types of formula” nhs.uk

  • NHS — “Food allergy” nhs.uk

  • American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren — “Choosing an Infant Formula” healthychildren.org

  • American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren — “How to Safely Prepare Formula with Water” healthychildren.org

Updated November 2026